The lesson of How to Cheat a Dragon’s Curse, the fourth book of Cressida Cowell’s How To Train Your Dragon series, is that fate can be altered and your own luck can be made by you—which is interestingly contrasted with the prophecies scattered throughout these plots and the patrilineal monarchy of the Viking tribe of which the book’s hero, Hiccup Horrendous Haddock III, is a part. Hiccup will (unless something happens to him) become chief of the Hairy Hooligans. If Hiccup does not survive to take up the chieftaincy, his cousin, Snotface Snotlout, will take his place. I’m interested to see if, as the series, progresses, Cowell plays with this newly introduced concept of creating luck and altering fate against the seemingly fixed destiny of her hero, whom the reader from the beginning knows will become a famous Viking hero, the series being written as a set of his memoirs, and the elder Hiccup telling “this story as if it happened to somebody else, because the boy [he] once was is so distant to [him] now, that he might as well be a stranger” (Prologue, How To Twist a Dragon’s Tale).
Probably the star here is the ludicrous ideas of a medieval culture that believed that the world was flat. Hiccup seeks the vegetable-that-no-one-dares-name, a potato, a strange probably imaginary plant from the mythical land of America. Yet, only a potato can counteract the deadly poison of the Venomous Vorpent, and Hiccup needs that cure badly.
The book does teach readers to stand up for, protect, and cling to friends, which ordinarily I would think to be a incontestably good lesson, but Hiccup clings to Fishlegs against his father’s command. While children need to learn whom to befriend and whom they should not, and parents can misjudge children, parents often have a good sense about whether or not their children’s friends are positive or negative influences, and I’m not sure that teaching children to flout their parents’ judgment is ideal—however flawed Stoick the Vast’s judgments have proved in the past—and they have proved to be quite poor, and I would have Hiccup cling to Fishlegs, especially in lieu of his father’s suggestion that Hiccup befriend his bullying cousin, Snotlout.
Before I could finish a review of How to Cheat a Dragon’s Curse, I went ahead and listened to the audiobook, read by David Tennant, of the fifth book in the series, How to Twist a Dragon’s Tale, so now I can answer some of the questions that I was posing in the review of book 4.
As yet, Cowell has done little with book 4’s lesson about the opportunity to change fate, other than to remind that readers that it’s never too late to do something heroic. I suppose the primary moral of this tale is best summed up by Stoick the Vast: “WE WILL NEVER SURRENDER!” (69). The primary quest of How to Twist a Dragon’s Tale is one to stop a volcano from exploding and hatching a flock of rare and particularly vicious Exterminator Dragons.
How to Twist a Dragon’s Tale sees the return of Hiccup’s arch-enemy, Alvin the Treacherous, still not dead, and it introduces a very Harry Potter-like element to Hiccup’s and Alvin’s conflict (with Alvin having created his own worst enemy in Hiccup, and yes, I fear that concept was used by Rowling first). We also learn more about Hiccup’s mother, a very shadowy woman, mentioned previously really only by name and as possessing an “extra-strong, heavy-duty bra” (How to Train Your Dragon 169). She still does not make much of an appearance and seems to be a rather absent parent, being too busy questing to be at home with her family, but her back story and Stoick’s is delved into.
Cowell plays with the western fairy tale/hero story clichés, having riders on white and black dragons.
This is the first of her books where dragons are ridden. Still no Night Furies, but Hiccup now has a lame Windwalker, too young yet to fly, but he will carry Hiccup along the ground. Could this be the inspiration for the half-tailed Toothless of Dreamworks’? Hiccup’s Windwalker is illustrated more darkly than other dragons, so I’m supposing that he is black. The Windwalker as yet has no name.
The illustrations are particularly emotive. I after listening to the audiobook, opened the book that I had and looked at the illustrations.
I especially enjoyed David Tennant singing with the many voices of the Vikings in this book.
Cowell, Cressida. How To Train Your Dragon, Book 4: How To Cheat a Dragon’s Curse. 2006. New York: Little, Brown-Hachette, 2010.
Cowell, Cressida. How To Train Your Dragon, Book 5: How to Twist a Dragon’s Tale. 2007. New York: Little, Brown-Hachette, 2010.
Cowell, Cressida. How to Train Your Dragon, Book 5: How to Twist a Dragon’s Tale. Narr. David Tennant. Hodder Children’s Audio: 2007. Audio recording.
This review is not endorsed by Cressida Cowell, David Tennant, Hodder Children’s Audio, or Little, Brown, and Company, part of Hachette Book Group. It is an independent, honest review by a reader.